Speaking to reporters upon arriving at the COP31 U.N. Climate Change Conference in Antalya, Turkey, Swedish “climate activist” Greta Thunberg stated: “We should act to protect and benefit people rather than constantly sacrificing the global majority and the very planet we are all living on, for a fortunate few to keep making unimaginable profits and maintaining geopolitical power.”
The irony is clear. The climate-crisis narrative she champions has long been advanced and funded by the kind of circles of concentrated wealth and influence she decries—billionaire philanthropists, large foundations, financial institutions, and corporate interests that have poured resources into alarmist messaging and related policy campaigns. Far from pure grassroots, the story of CO2 as the sole driver of catastrophe has been shaped by well-resourced actors whose profits and power are often tied to the policies the narrative demands.
That narrative treats carbon dioxide as the principal control knob for global temperature. The CO2 Coalition’s latest Climate Chronicles episode, “CO2 and Temperature,” examines the historical record and finds little evidence for the claim. Key points from the video:
- Over the past 8,000 years, ice-core data show overall temperature trends generally declined even as CO₂ levels increased.
- During the Medieval Warm Period, temperatures were likely warmer than today while CO2 levels were more than 30% lower.
- Temperature and CO2 do not always move in lockstep; CO2 is one factor among many.
- Temperatures bottomed out a little over 400 years ago during the Little Ice Age, then began recovering as natural cycles reversed and beneficial warming began.
- More significant warming started more than 300 years ago as solar and terrestrial cycles (orbital variations and ocean currents) returned to a phase of increasing temperatures—forces far more powerful than the mild greenhouse effect of CO2.
- At the peak of the last glacial advance 18,000 years ago, CO2 dropped to some of the lowest levels in Earth’s history; concentrations later rose modestly to and began increasing further in the 1800s, accelerating in the 20th century.
- Significant CO2 increases occurred well after the warming had already begun, not before.
- From 1943 to 1976, CO2 rose sharply amid post-World War II economic activity, yet the Earth cooled for three decades, prompting widespread speculation of a coming glacial advance.
- After warming resumed in the late 1970s, temperatures paused from 1997 to 2014 while CO2 continued to rise.
- Across 4.6 billion years, high CO2 has sometimes coincided with warmth and sometimes not; the two have often moved in opposite directions. Current warming remains modest and benign compared with many natural periods and is influenced by multiple factors, not solely by CO2.
For the full examination, see our Climate Chronicles video “CO₂ and Temperature,” at https://youtu.be/yNl2ubUAyXI. We hope you’ll support our efforts to research and share the truth about the benefits of CO2. |